Revenue Finance Guide Advances, factoring and revenue deals, with the arithmetic shown.

Revenue Finance Guide

FACTORING

Recourse vs Non-Recourse Factoring: Who Eats the Unpaid Invoice

By Baruch Mackliff · · 6 min read

Recourse decides who buys back an unpaid invoice, and non-recourse covers a narrower event than the name suggests, usually only the customer's insolvency.

Your factoring agreement says the arrangement is with recourse, and the rep waved it off as standard language. It is standard language. It is also the sentence that decides who absorbs a 50,000 dollar invoice when your customer stops answering the phone.

Recourse means you buy the invoice back. The factor advanced cash against a receivable, the receivable went bad, and the contract routes the loss to you. Non-recourse means the factor absorbs it, except the coverage is narrower than the name suggests. In most agreements it applies to a single cause of non-payment, the customer going insolvent, and only where nothing on your side contributed. Everything else still finds its way back to you, under a different heading.

How the money actually moves

Factoring is a sale. You sell a receivable at a discount, and the factor collects it from your customer directly, usually after a notice of assignment tells that customer where to send the check.

Take a 50,000 dollar invoice on 60 day terms. The factor advances 85 percent, so 42,500 reaches your account within a day or two of verification. The remaining 7,500 is the reserve. It stays with the factor until the customer pays.

When payment lands, the reserve is released to you minus the discount fee. Say the fee runs one and a half percent of face for each 30 day period and the customer pays on day 55. You have been charged for two periods, 1,500 dollars, so 6,000 of the reserve comes back.

Total cash to you, 48,500 on a 50,000 invoice, and you held most of it 55 days earlier than you otherwise would have. That is the transaction doing its job. Cash out of a balance sheet asset that was going to sit there regardless.

Now the other case.

What recourse triggers, and when

The agreement names a recourse period. 60 days past the invoice due date is common. So is 90. Some run longer, and a few start the clock at the invoice date rather than the due date, which quietly shortens the window by whatever your terms are.

When the clock runs out with the invoice unpaid, the factor charges it back.

Charging back means something specific here. The factor does not send you a bill and wait for a check. It takes the 42,500 out of your next funding, or debits the account it already has authorization to debit, or applies the reserve it is holding on every other invoice of yours.

So the week you work out that a customer has gone quiet is the same week your factoring line stops producing cash, because the cash it would have produced is being pointed at the buyback instead. Owners tend to describe this as the factor cutting them off in a panic. What is happening is arithmetic, and it was written down in advance.

Two questions worth asking before you sign anything. Does the factor have to give you notice before it charges an invoice back, or can it simply happen inside a settlement report you read on a Friday? And can a charged-back invoice be replaced with a different invoice of equal value instead of with cash? Some agreements permit the substitution and some are silent on it. The silent ones default to cash, which is the version that hurts, because cash is the thing you were short of when you started factoring.

What non-recourse actually covers

Read the definition. The phrase on the cover page is a marketing summary of a clause that lives a great deal later in the document.

In most non-recourse agreements the factor is assuming credit risk and nothing beyond it. Credit risk, defined tightly, means the customer became financially unable to pay. A bankruptcy filing. An assignment for the benefit of creditors. A receiver walking in.

Slow payment is none of those. A customer who pays everybody in nine months is solvent, and you own that risk. A customer who withholds payment because the delivery arrived short is solvent, and you own that one too. A customer applying an offset from a job you did last spring is solvent. And so on down the list of reasons an invoice goes unpaid that have nothing to do with anyone running out of money.

There is a second boundary worth finding. Non-recourse coverage is usually granted customer by customer, up to an approved limit the factor sets after underwriting that particular account. Invoice past the limit and the excess is recourse paper sitting inside an agreement you are paying non-recourse pricing for.

The warranties are the real exposure

Here is the part that surprises people who paid extra for the better label.

When you sell an invoice you make representations about it. The usual ones: the goods were delivered or the service was performed, the amount is correct and uncontested, no other party holds a lien on it, the customer has no right of setoff against it, and the invoice is neither a duplicate nor a rebill of something already sold.

Break any of those and the factor can require you to repurchase. That obligation is not the recourse clause. It sits in its own section, it applies to recourse and non-recourse agreements alike, and it exists because you sold something other than what you said you were selling.

Which means the most common route to a non-recourse client eating an invoice runs nowhere near the customer's finances. The customer pushed back on the work. The invoice became contested. The warranty failed. The invoice came home.

Choosing, and what to read first

Non-recourse costs more. You are buying insurance against one named event, and the premium is folded into the discount rate rather than billed separately, which makes it easy to lose track of what you are paying for.

It earns its price when your receivables are concentrated. Half your revenue sitting in two accounts means one insolvency takes the year, and handing that specific risk to somebody with an underwriting department is a sane trade. It earns much less when your book is spread across thirty smaller accounts and no single failure would move the needle, because you have already done the thing the insurance does.

Four things to locate in the document before you sign either version:

Read the verification language too. A factor who telephones your customer to confirm each invoice before funding is protecting both of you from the warranty problem above. A factor who skips verification is faster to fund, which feels like a benefit until the first contested invoice, at which point you find out the speed was borrowed against your own balance sheet.

The label on the cover tells you who absorbs an insolvency. The warranty section tells you who absorbs everything else, and everything else is most of what goes wrong.

Common questions

what does with recourse mean in a factoring agreement?

It means you buy the invoice back if your customer fails to pay inside the recourse period. The factor recovers its advance by debiting your account or by holding the reserve on your other invoices. That buyback obligation is yours whatever the reason for the non-payment turns out to be.

is non-recourse factoring worth the extra cost?

It earns its price when your receivables are concentrated in a few large accounts, because one insolvency there would take the year. It earns much less across a wide book of small balances, where the risk is already spread out. Compare the difference in the discount rate against the size of your single largest customer balance.

can a factor charge back an invoice under a non-recourse agreement?

Yes, through the warranty section rather than the recourse clause. You represented that the goods were delivered, that the amount was correct and that no setoff existed, and a breach of any of those lets the factor require a repurchase. Non-recourse covers the customer's insolvency, while the warranties cover everything else.

More on this